Cheddar (26)

Agropur - Cheese Cheddar 3 Year Grand, 185 Gram, $10.16 avg/ea

Agropur - Cheese Cheddar 5 Year Grand, 180 Gram, $11.68 avg/ea

Balderson - Balderson Heritage 3YR Cheddar Cheese, 280 Gram, $13.99

Balderson's Heritage Canadian 3 Year Old Cheddar Cheese delivers a bold, complex flavour developed through careful aging. This expertly crafted extra old cheddar features a firm, crumbly texture and an extra sharp, tangy taste that is sure to please seasoned cheese lovers. Its pale yellow hue and rich, robust profile make it perfect for enjoying on its own or pairing with fine wines, charcuterie, or artisanal bread. Balderson's 3-year cheddar is the ideal choice for those who appreciate a deeply aged cheese with intense flavour and character in every bite. Since 1881, Balderson has been dedicated to aging premium cheese in Ontario. While the world has evolved, our commitment to quality and craftsmanship remains unchanged. Balderson cheese is a premium brand cherished by Canadians for over 140 years, known for its exceptional taste and meticulous attention to detail.

Balderson - One Year Old White Cheddar, 280 Gram, $11.99

Balderson's Championship Cheddar Cheese is crafted to deliver a perfectly balanced flavour with just the right amount of sharpness. Aged for 12 months, this premium cheese offers a smooth, creamy texture with a more rounded cheddar flavour that appeals to a wide range of old cheddar lovers. Its pale yellow colour and firm, yet sliceable consistency make it ideal for everything from gourmet sandwiches to cheese boards. Recognized for its award-winning quality, Balderson's Championship Cheddar is perfect for those who enjoy a refined, yet approachable cheddar with a subtle depth of flavour. Since 1881, Balderson has been dedicated to aging premium cheese in Ontario. While the world has evolved, our commitment to quality and craftsmanship remains unchanged. Balderson cheese is a premium brand cherished by Canadians for over 140 years, known for its exceptional taste and meticulous attention to detail.

Balderson - Royal Canadian White Cheddar, 280 Gram, $12.99

Balderson's 2 Year Old Cheddar Cheese is carefully aged to develop a robust, full-bodied flavour with a satisfying sharpness. Over two years of maturation give this cheddar a firmer texture and a slightly crumbly consistency, perfect for those who appreciate a more intense, extra old cheddar. With its pale yellow colour and rich, tangy taste, Balderson's 2 year cheddar is an excellent choice for cheese lovers seeking depth and character in every bite. Ideal for pairing with crackers, fruit, or adding complexity to cooked dishes, it delivers a truly elevated cheese experience. Since 1881, Balderson has been dedicated to aging premium cheese in Ontario. While the world has evolved, our commitment to quality and craftsmanship remains unchanged. Balderson cheese is a premium brand cherished by Canadians for over 140 years, known for its exceptional taste and meticulous attention to detail.

Castello - Extra Mature Cheddar - Tickler, 200 Gram, $9.89

This is an extra mature cheddar with a sweet, tangy taste. It is carefully matured for up to 18 months & made by expert cheese makers at the Taw Valley Creamery in Devon. Pairs well with apples.

Castello - Strikingly Spicy Cheddar - Cracked Black Pepper, 200 Gram, $9.89

Notes of cracked pepper complement the unique sharp & sweet flavor of our Mature English Cheddar. For the Pepper Fan you know & to add bold spice to a charcuterie & cheeseboard.

Castello - Tickler 1 Year Cheddar, 200 Gram, $9.89

A good source of calcium.

Cathedral City - Extra Mature Cheese, 200 Gram, $9.99

The UKs #1 Cheddar! The carefully crafted Cathedral City Extra Mature Cheddar delivers a lovely firm texture and mouth-filling rich yet creamy flavour with every bite. Great for everyday or to savour on special occasions.

Choices - Cheese Cheddar 1 Year Aged Organic, 190 Gram, $11.38 avg/ea

Organic

Choices - Cheese Cheddar 3 Year Aged Organic, 210 Gram, $14.68 avg/ea

Organic

Choices - Cheese Cheddar Mild Organic, 175 Gram, $9.61 avg/ea

Choices - Cheese Marble Cheddar Organic, 180 Gram, $9.88 avg/ea

Organic

Collier's - Powerful Welsh Cheddar Cheese, 200 Gram, $13.99

Made with 100% Welsh milk.

Coombe Castle - Cheese Fiddler's Green, 200 Gram, $14.98 avg/ea

Cows Creamery - 1 Year Old Cheddar Cheese, 200 Gram, $13.99

Gluten Free, Nut Free, Wheat Free

Cows Creamery - 2 Year Old Cheddar Cheese, 200 Gram, $14.99

Gluten Free, Nut Free, Wheat Free

Cows Creamery - 3 Year Old Cheddar Cheese, 200 Gram, $15.99

Gluten Free, Nut Free, Wheat Free

Cows Creamery - Cheese Applewood Smoked, 200 Gram, $14.98 avg/ea

Cows Creamery - Cheese Cheddar Extra Aged, 175 Gram, $12.23 avg/ea

Ilchester - Cheese Cheddar English Applewood Smoked, 180 Gram, $13.48 avg/ea

Irish Wexford - Cheddar Cheese Mature, 200 Gram, $11.99

Kerrygold - Dubliner Cheese, 200 Gram, $9.99

100% Natural Cheese. Made with Natural Ingredients. 31% M.F.. 37% Moisture. Hard Ripened Cheese with a Distinctive Taste and a Natural Hint of Sweetness. Imported From Ireland.

Kerrygold - Reserve Cheddar, 200 Gram, $9.99

Made with Natural Ingredients. Aged Over 2 Years. Distinctly Sharp Aged Cheddar Cheese.

Truly Grass Fed - Cheddar Cheese Mature, 198 Gram, $9.99

Truly Grass Fed - Cheddar Cheese Medium, 198 Gram, $9.99